Before you buy, trade or sign up

Store Policies

Returns, trade-ins, house rules, rewards and pull list subscriptions, all in one place.

Return Policy

  • All sales on comics, graphic novels and trading card game products (Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Lorcana, Star Wars: Unlimited and others) are final. No returns or exchanges once you have left the store or opened the product.
  • Unopened games, toys and puzzles may be returned within 30 days for store credit or a refund.
  • All sales on used products are final.
  • Due to multiple fraudulent transactions, any Pokémon purchase over $25 requires your name, email and phone number (the same details as the rewards program). This is not required if you pay with cash.
  • Online returns may carry shipping and restocking fees.
  • For online orders, we send several reminders to pick up. An order left unclaimed after 90 days is considered abandoned.

Trade-In Policy

What we accept

  • Gold and silver age comics
  • Comic "keys" (first appearances, "death of" issues and the like)
  • Pokémon and Magic singles worth $5 or more
  • Funko Pops
  • Used toys (Star Wars figures, for example)
  • Used graphic novels

What we do not accept

  • Yu-Gi-Oh! or Lorcana singles
  • Sports trading cards
  • Video games

How offers work. Offers depend on condition, local market conditions and fair market value (FMV) on sites such as TCGplayer, eBay and CovrPrice.

Current trade-in rates, as a share of FMV

  • Comics and toys: 30% in cash, or 50% in store credit
  • Pokémon: 40% in cash, or 60% in store credit
  • Magic: 50% in cash, or 70% in store credit

General Conduct

  • Be respectful of your fellow gamers. We have no tolerance for harassment of any kind.
  • Proxies are not allowed in any officially sanctioned event.
  • Well-behaved, leashed pets are allowed.
  • Outside food and drink are allowed. Please keep the gaming area clean.
  • Demo games are free to play in the store. Treat them with respect and return them in good condition.
  • Please do not read unpurchased comics or graphic novels in the store.
  • Painting miniatures is allowed. You are responsible for cleaning up after yourself.
  • Please put any trash in the receptacles provided.

Rewards Program

  • It is free to join. We need your name, email and phone number.
  • We may send periodic emails about events, sales and other store updates (newsletters are generally weekly). Join, change or stop the emails on our email preferences page.
  • Earn 10 points for every dollar you spend.
  • At 1,000 points, redeem a $5 credit.
  • Credits can be redeemed in amounts of 5, 10, 25, 50, 75 or 100 dollars. The maximum discount is 100 dollars.
  • Credits cannot be combined with any other credit or discount, and you cannot combine multiple reward credits.

Subscription Service

Every subscriber gets:

  • A discount on subscribed comics: 5% for 1 to 9 subscriptions, 10% for 10 or more.
  • Free bags and boards for all comics.
  • First access to ratio variants.
  • Guaranteed pulls, when your subscription starts before the FOC.

When you sign up, use the same email you use for the Bat City Games & Comics rewards program. Read how a pull list works. Questions? Write to info@batcitygc.com.