Color identity: 2 colors
Commander

The Commander Dispatch

A Commander story, told round by round with real cards, four colors and the rules explained as they come up.

The Bat City Crew12 min read

Commander

The Commander Dispatch

A Commander story, told round by round with real cards, four colors and the rules explained as they come up.

People ask us what a Commander game is actually like, and the honest answer is that it’s a long, loud, four-person argument conducted in spells. So here’s one. The game is invented, the cards are real, and the colors have been left to behave like themselves.

Your correspondent has a folding chair at the back of the room, a notebook, and no stake in the outcome. Four colors are at war. Blue counts everything twice. Red has never once waited. White has read the rules and would like you to hear them. Green is quietly growing something.

A quick briefing before the shooting starts. In Commander, every player brings a 100-card deck built around a legendary creature called a commander, with one copy of each card (basic lands aside). The commander starts the game in the command zone, a waiting area beside the battlefield, and can be cast from there whenever you can afford it. Everyone starts at 40 life. Last one standing wins.

ROUND ZERO

Before a single card is played, the table has the talk Commander calls Rule 0: what kind of game does everybody want? It’s the most important rule in the format, and it’s really just a conversation.

WHITE: asks whether everyone wants a casual game. Says “Casual?”

BLUE: shuffles without looking up. Says “Casual.”

RED: is already holding seven cards. Says “Can we start?”

GREEN: shrugs. Says “Whatever the table likes.”

That was the lowest setting, for the record. White is keeping the record. (The long version, with brackets and table politics, lives in our how-to-play Magic guide.)

ROUND ONE

Everyone has seven cards in hand and a commander waiting in the command zone. Blue goes first. The room goes quiet in the way a room does just before it stops being quiet.

BLUE: plays an Island, then Sol Ring (it costs one mana and makes two every turn after that), all on turn one. Says “Just a little rock.” The table groans.

RED: plays a Mountain and passes with nothing to cast. Says “Fine.” Red watches the Sol Ring the way you’d watch a stranger’s dessert.

WHITE: plays Command Tower, a land that makes mana in your commander’s color identity (the colors on your commander, which your whole deck has to stay inside). White’s commander is white, so the Tower makes white. Says, “It’s a Plains with a nicer name.”

GREEN: plays a Forest and Llanowar Elves (a one-mana Elf that taps for a green mana). Says “Hello.”

ROUND TWO

Blue has two lands and a Sol Ring, which is four mana to everyone else’s two. The word for this is ramp: getting more mana than your land drops allow. Green does it on purpose. Blue just got lucky.

BLUE: plays an Island, then Rhystic Study (whenever an opponent casts a spell, Blue draws a card unless that player pays one mana). Says, “It’s fine. You’re all welcome to pay.”

RED: plays a Mountain and passes again, holding a hand full of things that cost more than two. Says, “I’m going to hurt somebody.”

WHITE: plays a Plains and leaves one white mana open. Says “Nothing.” (It’s Swords to Plowshares, which exiles a creature for one mana, even on someone else’s turn. The creature’s controller gains life equal to its power, which is white’s version of an apology.)

GREEN: plays a Forest and, with Llanowar Elves, has three mana. Casts Ezuri, Renegade Leader straight from the command zone on turn two. Green can’t pay for Rhystic Study, so Blue draws. Says “Hello again.”

(If a commander dies or is exiled, it can go back to the command zone, and every trip back costs two more mana to recast. That’s commander tax. Ezuri is going to pay a lot of it.)

ROUND THREE

White says it out loud: “Green’s the problem.” It’s the most important sentence in multiplayer Magic. There are no teams in Commander, and every alliance lasts exactly as long as someone looks more dangerous than you do.

BLUE: plays an Island and casts Talrand, Sky Summoner (a wizard who makes a 2/2 flying Drake every time Blue casts an instant or sorcery). Says, “Every spell makes a Drake now. Small ones.”

RED: plays a Mountain and casts Hordeling Outburst: three 1/1 Goblins. Forgets the Rhystic Study tax, so Blue draws. Says “Look at them!”

WHITE: plays a Plains and taps out for Adeline, Resplendent Cathar (whenever you attack, a 1/1 Human soldier joins in for each opponent, already attacking). Says “I’m only saying.”

GREEN: plays a Forest and casts Imperious Perfect (the other Elves get +1/+1, and for one green mana it makes a new Elf every turn). Pays the Rhystic Study tax with its last mana. Says “Thank you.” Green always pays the tax.

ROUND FOUR

Round four is when the table starts reading each other’s open mana. It’s a real skill, it has no name, and everyone claims they weren’t doing it.

BLUE: plays an Island and does nothing, with six mana open (Counterspell, which stops any spell for two blue mana, is in hand). Says “Go ahead.”

RED: plays a Mountain and casts Krenko, Mob Boss (it taps to make a Goblin for every Goblin you control, so the pile doubles each turn). Taps out, so Blue draws. Says “Now we’re talking.”

Blue lets Krenko resolve. Blue has plans.

WHITE: plays a Plains and keeps one white mana open. Doesn’t attack. Says “Twenty-one combat damage from one commander kills you. I’m counting.” (Nobody has dealt any. In multiplayer, the first player to attack becomes the next threat, and White knows it.)

GREEN: plays a Forest and casts Cultivate (it fetches two basic lands, one to the battlefield and one to the hand), leaving two Forests untapped. Skips the Rhystic Study tax this time, so Blue draws. Says “Just gardening.”

Nobody asks why Green is leaving two green mana open. (Somebody should.)

ROUND FIVE

Here’s where it happens. Nine creatures on the table, three players with a grudge, and one open question, which is still Green.

BLUE: plays an Island and casts Treachery on Krenko, stealing Red’s commander. Treachery costs five and untaps five lands when it arrives, so it’s free. Says, “Thank you for this. It’s lovely.”

Blue can’t tap Krenko yet. (A creature that comes under your control can’t use a tap ability until you’ve held it since the start of your turn. It’s called summoning sickness, and it’s the only luck Red has this round.)

RED: looks at nine creatures (Blue’s Talrand and Krenko, three Goblins, White’s Adeline, and Green’s Llanowar Elves, Ezuri and Imperious Perfect) and casts Blasphemous Act: 13 damage to every creature, and it costs one less for each creature on the battlefield. With nine out there, all the generic mana vanishes and it costs a single red mana. Pays the Rhystic Study tax out of pure spite. Says “Everybody calm down.” (Red has bats in the belfry. The belfry is on fire.)

GREEN, in response: spends its two open Forests on Ezuri’s ability (one green mana: regenerate another target Elf) and saves Llanowar Elves and Imperious Perfect. Ezuri can’t save himself, because the word on the card is “another.” Says nothing.

Every commander at the table dies and goes back to the command zone. The tax is two more per trip.

WHITE: recasts Adeline for five (three, plus two for the tax) and taps out. Blue draws. Says “Rules are rules.”

GREEN, on its own turn: recasts Ezuri for five, taps Imperious Perfect for a fresh Elf, and pays the tax. Says “Hello again again.”

ROUNDS SIX TO NINE

Four rounds in one paragraph, because nobody remembers all of it, including the people who were there. Round Five cleared the board, and every commander has been back to the command zone at least once. The war is over. The grudges are not.

BLUE: recasts Talrand for six (four, plus two). Keeps drawing off Rhystic Study because everyone forgets the tax, and keeps two Islands open for Counterspell every single turn. Says “Go ahead.”

RED: spends these rounds on revenge instead of rebuilding. Casts Zealous Conscripts, steals White’s Adeline for a turn, and attacks White with her. Adeline’s trigger fires for Red, so Red gets a Human soldier for each opponent and keeps all three. (Krenko doesn’t come back until Round Nine, for six.) Says, “I’m just borrowing her.”

WHITE: casts Swords to Plowshares on Ezuri. Green gains three life, and Ezuri goes back to the command zone for the second time. Says, “It’s always Green.”

GREEN: casts Elvish Visionary (an Elf that draws a card when it arrives), then recasts Ezuri for seven (three, plus two for each trip back). Taps Perfect for a new Elf every turn. Says “I’m fine. Please keep looking at each other.”

They do. By the end of Round Nine, Blue is at 8 life, Red is at 10, White is at 7, and Green, who everyone swore they were watching, has nine Elves.

ROUND TEN

Green has nine Elves, eleven lands and a plan. The table has been pointing at Green since Round Three. Nobody thought to count the Elves.

BLUE: passes with two Islands open. Says “Go ahead.”

RED: taps Krenko for a single Goblin. Says “Anybody?”

WHITE: passes with nothing open, because the Swords is long gone. Says “I’d like it noted that I said so in Round Three.”

GREEN: pays the Rhystic Study tax and casts Overrun (every creature Green controls gets +3/+3 and trample until end of turn).

BLUE, in response: casts Counterspell on Overrun. Talrand makes Blue a Drake. Blue is thrilled. Says “Nice try.”

GREEN: attacks with all nine Elves. The table blocks, because Overrun is gone and the Elves look small. Then Green pays five more for Ezuri’s other ability: every Elf gets +3/+3 and trample. Says “Hello, everyone.”

Overrun, the tax and Ezuri come to eleven mana, and Green has exactly eleven lands. Every Elf is now at least a 5/5 with trample (a 1/1 plus one from Imperious Perfect and three from Ezuri, and Ezuri himself is a 6/6). A blocker soaks up only as much damage as its toughness, and the rest tramples through. White counts out loud, which is the best part of White.

That’s the game. Round ten, last minute, won by the player the whole table spent nine rounds pointing at. Green starts shuffling for the next one.

The catch

If you want something easygoing, Commander may not be for you. It’s quick and brutal, even on the “lowest” Rule 0 setting, and the winner is often the player everybody swore they were watching. We love it anyway.

Design diary

Notes from the folding chair, for anyone who wants to check your correspondent’s work. Nobody actually played this game. We built it backward from the ending, using Commander’s rules as they stand now: 40 life, 100-card decks with one copy of each card, a commander in the command zone, two extra mana each time it’s been cast before, and a loss for anyone who takes 21 combat damage from a single commander. Black sat this one out, so the table is four colors.

The math, for people who check. Blasphemous Act costs nine mana, less one for each creature on the battlefield. Nine creatures would take the whole cost away, but a colored symbol can’t be discounted, so it costs a single red mana. Two open Forests paid for two regenerations. In Round Ten, Green has eleven lands (ten land drops plus one from Cultivate) and spends every one: five on Overrun, one on the tax, five on Ezuri. Nine Elves, three at each opponent, is fifteen trample damage apiece, and blockers soak up only their toughness. Blue is at 8 with Talrand and a Drake, both 2/2, so four points get soaked, and eleven get through. Red is at 10 with four 1/1 blockers (the Goblin and the three Human soldiers), so four points get soaked, and eleven get through. White is at 7 with Adeline, toughness four, so four get soaked, and eleven get through. Everyone takes more than they have.

A few points of interest. Four of the eighteen cards in the story (Sol Ring, Counterspell, Swords to Plowshares and Llanowar Elves) were in the first Magic set, Alpha, in 1993. Overrun is from 1997, Treachery from 1999, and Rhystic Study from 2000. The newest card here is Adeline, from 2021. Commander is the format that lets all of them sit at one table.

And if you’re keeping a list of the curveballs: the iffy cards were Rhystic Study and Treachery, the game breakers were Sol Ring and Overrun, and the total betrayals were Treachery on Krenko and Zealous Conscripts on Adeline.

Come play it

The best way to learn Commander is to sit down at a table with three other people and one deck. Tell us you’re new at the counter, and we’ll find you an open seat. If you’d like a deck of your own first, our Commander decks are a good place to start.

Come to Commander Night on Wednesdays, 6 to 10 PM, and see what your own dispatch looks like!

Bat City Games & Comics is at 5001 Highway 290, Austin, Texas 78735.

EveryWED6 to 10 PM

Commander Night

Tell us at the counter you are new, and we will find you an open seat. Every Wednesday.

See the calendar