Jean Grey and the Phoenix: A History Before Her New Series
Jean Grey gets her own five-issue series on November 25. Here is her history, the story everyone argues about, and where to start reading.
The Bat City Crew8 min read
Jean Grey and the Phoenix: A History Before Her New Series
Jean Grey gets her own five-issue series on November 25. Here is her history, the story everyone argues about, and where to start reading.
Jean Grey gets her own series on November 25. Jean Grey #1 is the first of five issues, written by Jed MacKay with art by Rogê Antônio. It is a good excuse to find out why people have argued about this character since 1963. If you met her in the X-Men '97 cartoon, or on screen this year in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, this guide is for you.
A note before we start. The older stories below are decades old, and we will spoil them. The new series we will not.
Who is Jean Grey?
Jean Grey is a telepath and telekinetic, one of the five original X-Men, and the center of the most famous story in the team's history. She has gone by two code names, Marvel Girl and Phoenix. Over sixty years she has also been dead, alive, a copy, dead, a teenager from the past, dead, a cosmic force, a godlike miracle... and not always in that order.
1963: The O5
Stan Lee and Jack Kirby introduced her in X-Men #1, cover-dated September 1963. The founding team was Cyclops, Beast, Angel, Iceman and Marvel Girl, students at Professor X's school for gifted youngsters. Marvel Girl could move objects with her mind, and played a bit of a Smurfette role: The rich one, the uptight one, the funny one, the smart one, and the girl one. The 1970s gave her a lot more to do.
1976: Enter the Phoenix
In the mid-1970s, writer Chris Claremont and artist Dave Cockrum were rebuilding the X-Men with a new, international team. In X-Men #100, cover-dated August 1976, Jean pilots a shuttle into trouble. In the issues that follow, the cosmic Phoenix Force answers her call amid a crisis, and Jean emerges as the Phoenix. Fans named this run, Uncanny X-Men #101 to #108, the Phoenix Saga.
1980: The Dark Phoenix Saga
Four years later came the story that made the character. Uncanny X-Men #129 to #138, written by Claremont and drawn by John Byrne, is the Dark Phoenix Saga. Jean's power keeps growing, the villain Mastermind twists her mind, and she becomes Dark Phoenix. A rampage that consumes a star follows, genociding a planet. The Shi'ar, an alien empire with a longtime grudge against the Phoenix, arrive, and the X-Men must decide what that means for their friend.
In issue 137, Jean makes a final choice. She would rather die than risk what the Phoenix might do next, and she says goodbye to Scott Summers, the teammate known as Cyclops and the man she loves.
It almost ended another way. The creators had planned for Jean to lose her powers and live. Editor-in-chief Jim Shooter ordered a rewrite so the story would carry a consequence. The original ending was published in 1984 in Phoenix: The Untold Story, the same year the saga was first collected in a trade paperback.
1986: She comes back
Fans never let Jean stay gone. In 1986, Roger Stern in Avengers #263 and John Byrne in Fantastic Four #286 revealed the truth. The Phoenix Force had made a duplicate of Jean, and the real Jean had been in a healing cocoon the whole time. They found her in a pod in the waters near New York. Then she rejoined Cyclops, Beast, Angel and Iceman in X-Factor #1, which reunited the original five.
Not everyone loved it. Chris Claremont, who wrote the original saga, has said he wishes she had stayed gone, because it took some of the danger out of the book. The move caught him by surprise, since Byrne arranged it in the pages of Fantastic Four.
After 1986: marriage, loss and return
- 1994: Jean and Scott marry, in the adjectiveless X-Men #30.
- 2001: Grant Morrison takes over the book as New X-meN, and in issue 150, in 2004, Jean dies again, reaching the White Hot Room of the Phoenix that comes back into importance during the Fall of X storyline.
- 2005: Greg Pak's Phoenix: Endsong brought the Phoenix back, but isn't very good in our opinion.
- Early 2010s: All-New X-Men by Brian Michael Bendis brought a teenage Jean forward in time from the original five's early days. Frankly unnecessary, but a big deal for the next few years.
-
Late 2017: Phoenix Resurrection: The Return of Jean Grey, by Matthew Rosenberg and Leinil Francis Yu, brought back grown-up Jean.
- X-Men Red: An underrated and rather short tale about a team led by Jean, in all her righteousness.
- Fall of X: A missable limited series by venerated X-books writer Louise Simonson, is a low-stakes journey through Jean's past, confronting her with her own righteousness and self-martyrdom. Interesting as a character study, because nobody knows Jean like Louise (maybe even more than Claremont!), but the stakes couldn't be lower and the pacing is a little bit... let's say, of an earlier age.
- X-Men Forever: With Jean almost dead and most of Krakoa's mutants adrift in the White Hot Room (technically dead, although nobody ever says this and they get better), Hope Summers and Jean Grey work together to save the universe, giving rebirth to the Phoenix and even explaining Hope's parentage in the process.
It's hard to keep track! We hang upside down for a living, and even we lose track of which way is up.
What is the Phoenix, anyway?
Life and Fire Incarnate, the white-hot burning truth, the Phoenix burns off whatever doesn't work. That's why Jean's tactical but compassionate nature makes them a perfect fit. By the end of Gillen's X-Men Forever, it's made clear that Jean and the Phoenix are the same being, and why.
But historically, nobody has ever fully agreed, and that includes the people who made the story. An early idea was that the Phoenix was Jean's own power, grown huge. Later, John Byrne and editor Jim Salicrup described it as an outside entity that had taken her over. The team settled on the first version because it makes Jean responsible for what she does, and that is what gives the Dark Phoenix Saga its weight. Writers have kept bending the idea ever since. It is a handy thing to know before a series about Jean working out what the Phoenix is to her.
2026: Jean Grey #1
Marvel says the new series picks up with Jean returning to Earth after a stretch of adventuring in space as the Phoenix. The world she comes back to is not quite the one she left, and her return has major consequences for the X-Men and for Jean herself. She has to manage a power that gives life and takes it, and decide whether she can keep control. Marvel's preview opens with a flashback to her early days under Professor X, then jumps to the present.
Jean Grey #1 arrives on November 25, a Wednesday, so it is new comics day. The lead-in, DNX, started September 2. MacKay writes it with artist Federico Vicentini, bringing the X-Men and the Fantastic Four together. Marvel says the fallout spreads across several titles, and Jean's return is part of it.
Where to start
- The classic. The Dark Phoenix Saga, Uncanny X-Men #129 to #138, is still the one to read. We did not find a collected edition in our listings, so ask at the counter what is in this week.
- The return. X-Factor: The Original X-Men Omnibus, Volume 1 is listed in stock as we write this. It is where Jean rejoins the original five.
- The new series. Jean Grey #1 on November 25 is a first issue, so it is a fair place to jump in. DNX, the lead-in, started September 2.
- The rest of the story. The marriage, the fantastic and pivotal Morrison run and the 2017 return all have their own collections. Ask us, and we will point you to what is on the shelf.
For anything still running, a pull list is the easy way to follow along. Tell us the title and we set aside every issue under your name. You can start a pull list or ask at the counter.
Ready to take a seat?
Come in on a Wednesday, when new comics land, and tell us you want Jean Grey. Stock changes, so ask what we have. We are open every day, 10 AM to 10 PM.
Visit Bat City Games & Comics at 5001 Highway 290, Austin, Texas 78735, in Sunset Valley.
Keep reading: Where to start with Absolute Batman · Wednesday at the shop
New Comics Day
New comics land every Wednesday. Tell us you want Jean Grey, and we will set aside the new series and point you to where it starts.